|
Post by powerof0ne on Sept 15, 2011 13:14:47 GMT -5
I'd like to add a few things...Seattle is one of the nicest instructors and competitors I think any of you would ever meet. If all of us were half as open and nice as him, I don't think there would be any political tension.
With that being said, I believe the mods, Milkman, and myself don't mind if you criticize bad judging regardless of the organization, especially if it's intelligent criticism like Kurisu made. We just don't want to see something like, "The IKO20s judging sucked!" Detailed and intelligent criticism can truly be used as a learning tool. If you don't agree with somebody, don't just reply, "I don't agree," LOL...debate them with your reasons why.
Really the only other "main rule" is, don't put K4L down, there are a lot of good people on there, and I know many of us still post on there, as well. I wouldn't want somebody talking bad behind my back.
Now I'll go back to our regularly scheduled program. All of you on here are awesome and I probably won't mention any "rules" again for 6 months or so. I was saying this because I know a few of you are new on here, you haven't even violated these common sense rules. Just a friendly "for your information." Osu!
|
|
|
Post by Kurisu on Sept 15, 2011 22:53:35 GMT -5
That's why that call didn't make sense. Thanks for the clarification. This was scheduled as a two round fight, so most of the intermission is cut out (1 minute), So what you see is Shiro conceding the match. That is why the flags and signaling at the end does not make sense. Most of the judges did not a lot of knockdown judging experience. There were some mistakes made, but they were consistent in there calls and rulings for the entire day. Good or bad. For that I give them credit, and most of them were judging as instructed. Some of the calls I did not like, but the only way to avoid that is to win in the first 30 seconds, game over, which I did not do. There are not that many really good Shushin or Fukushin.
|
|
|
Post by Kurisu on Sept 15, 2011 22:54:33 GMT -5
Did I miss something?? LOL I'd like to add a few things...Seattle is one of the nicest instructors and competitors I think any of you would ever meet. If all of us were half as open and nice as him, I don't think there would be any political tension. With that being said, I believe the mods, Milkman, and myself don't mind if you criticize bad judging regardless of the organization, especially if it's intelligent criticism like Kurisu made. We just don't want to see something like, "The IKO20s judging sucked!" Detailed and intelligent criticism can truly be used as a learning tool. If you don't agree with somebody, don't just reply, "I don't agree," LOL...debate them with your reasons why. Really the only other "main rule" is, don't put K4L down, there are a lot of good people on there, and I know many of us still post on there, as well. I wouldn't want somebody talking bad behind my back. Now I'll go back to our regularly scheduled program. All of you on here are awesome and I probably won't mention any "rules" again for 6 months or so. I was saying this because I know a few of you are new on here, you haven't even violated these common sense rules. Just a friendly "for your information." Osu!
|
|
|
Post by powerof0ne on Sept 15, 2011 23:13:16 GMT -5
Did I miss something?? LOL I'd like to add a few things...Seattle is one of the nicest instructors and competitors I think any of you would ever meet. If all of us were half as open and nice as him, I don't think there would be any political tension. With that being said, I believe the mods, Milkman, and myself don't mind if you criticize bad judging regardless of the organization, especially if it's intelligent criticism like Kurisu made. We just don't want to see something like, "The IKO20s judging sucked!" Detailed and intelligent criticism can truly be used as a learning tool. If you don't agree with somebody, don't just reply, "I don't agree," LOL...debate them with your reasons why. Really the only other "main rule" is, don't put K4L down, there are a lot of good people on there, and I know many of us still post on there, as well. I wouldn't want somebody talking bad behind my back. Now I'll go back to our regularly scheduled program. All of you on here are awesome and I probably won't mention any "rules" again for 6 months or so. I was saying this because I know a few of you are new on here, you haven't even violated these common sense rules. Just a friendly "for your information." Osu! No, you didn't miss anything . I said the above to possibly prevent any hard feelings, or worst. I for one, love intelligent criticism & debates, and encourage it. I go on another knockdown forum which I won't name, where I see some blatant disregard for other organizations. I just don't want to see that happen here, is all. As far as I know, nobody on here goes on said forum, but there is a good chance I'm wrong. Osu!
|
|
|
Post by seattle on Sept 16, 2011 0:53:35 GMT -5
That's why that call didn't make sense. Thanks for the clarification. No problem, it was a non standard tournament format. You were spot on regarding the judges mechanics, I just wanted to say they were overall fair. What they enforced or did not enforce they did pretty much the same for everybody. Next fight, when I kick the guy in the head it needs to get me a Ippon!
|
|
|
Post by seattle on Sept 16, 2011 0:54:13 GMT -5
I'd like to add a few things...Seattle is one of the nicest instructors and competitors I think any of you would ever meet. If all of us were half as open and nice as him, I don't think there would be any political tension. With that being said, I believe the mods, Milkman, and myself don't mind if you criticize bad judging regardless of the organization, especially if it's intelligent criticism like Kurisu made. We just don't want to see something like, "The IKO20s judging sucked!" Detailed and intelligent criticism can truly be used as a learning tool. If you don't agree with somebody, don't just reply, "I don't agree," LOL...debate them with your reasons why. Really the only other "main rule" is, don't put K4L down, there are a lot of good people on there, and I know many of us still post on there, as well. I wouldn't want somebody talking bad behind my back. Now I'll go back to our regularly scheduled program. All of you on here are awesome and I probably won't mention any "rules" again for 6 months or so. I was saying this because I know a few of you are new on here, you haven't even violated these common sense rules. Just a friendly "for your information." Osu! Very kind, sir. Arigato.
|
|